Alan Author strikes again: more on confirming conjunctions of disconfirmed hypotheses

The so-called Alan Author Effect is a surprising phenomenon in Bayesian Confirmation Theory. It occurs when a piece of evidence $e$ confirms the conjunction of two hypotheses $h1∧h2$ but at the same time disconfirms each hypothesis $h1$ and $h2$ individually. In this paper, I present a new and prima facie stronger version of this effect where additionally, the evidence $e$ confirms the conjunction of the negated hypotheses $¬h1∧¬h2$⁠. I say ‘prima facie’ because it can be shown that this seemingly stronger effect and the original effect are actually coextensional. I use this insight to formulate a new sufficient (and also necessary) condition for the two equivalent effects. I also examine how likely the two effects are to occur with the help of Monte Carlo simulation methods.